Should I Accept an Article 15 or Demand Trial by Court-Martial?

Most service members accept an Article 15 because the maximum punishment is limited and it is not a criminal conviction. Demanding trial by court-martial makes sense mainly when the evidence is weak, you have a real defense, and you are willing to accept the risk of a federal conviction and a punitive discharge if you lose. Talk to defense counsel before you sign anything; the decision is yours, not your commander’s.