Should I Accept an Article 15 or Demand Trial by Court-Martial?

Short answer: Most service members accept an Article 15 because the maximum punishment is limited and it is not a criminal conviction. Demanding trial by court-martial makes sense mainly when the evidence is weak, you have a real defense, and you are willing to accept the risk of a federal conviction and a punitive discharge if you lose. Talk to defense counsel before you sign anything; the decision is yours, not your commander’s.

Key takeaways

  • Unless you are attached to or embarked on a vessel, you have the right to refuse an Article 15 and demand trial.
  • Article 15 punishments are capped; court-martial punishments can include confinement, a federal conviction and a punitive discharge.
  • A court-martial requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt and follows the Military Rules of Evidence.
  • Refusing does not guarantee a court-martial; the command might drop the matter or choose administrative action instead.
  • You get time to consult a lawyer before deciding. Use it.

What is an Article 15?

An Article 15, also called nonjudicial punishment (NJP), captain’s mast (Navy) or office hours (Marine Corps), lets a commander punish minor misconduct without a trial. The commander hears the evidence, listens to you, decides whether you committed the offense, and imposes punishment. It is not a criminal conviction. See our Article 15 overview for the full process.

Article 15 vs. court-martial: what’s at stake

Article 15 (NJP) Court-martial
Who decides Your commander A military judge, or a panel of members
Standard of proof Army: beyond a reasonable doubt. Navy, Marine Corps, Air Force: preponderance of the evidence Beyond a reasonable doubt
Rules of evidence Do not apply Military Rules of Evidence apply
Lawyer at the hearing Right to consult; a spokesperson may attend Free military counsel plus civilian counsel of your choice
Maximum punishment Limited (e.g., reduction, forfeiture of half a month’s pay for two months, 45 days extra duty, 60 days restriction for field-grade NJP) Up to the maximum for the offense: confinement, dishonorable or bad-conduct discharge, total forfeitures
Criminal record Not a conviction A federal conviction at a special or general court-martial

When does accepting an Article 15 make sense?

  • The evidence is strong and you have no real legal defense.
  • The offense is minor and the command is offering NJP as a lenient option.
  • You want to limit exposure. Accepting caps the worst case at Article 15 punishments.
  • You can still present your side. Accepting an Article 15 does not mean admitting guilt. You can present evidence, call witnesses and argue that you did not commit the offense.

When does demanding court-martial make sense?

  • The evidence is weak or depends on one witness whose credibility is questionable.
  • Key evidence would be inadmissible at trial, for example an unwarned statement or an unlawful search.
  • The consequences of NJP are already career-ending, such as an Article 15 that would trigger mandatory separation processing, so there is less to lose.
  • You are innocent and willing to accept the risk to prove it.

Be realistic. If you demand trial and lose, the sentence can be much worse than any Article 15. A special or general court-martial conviction also follows you into civilian life. Commanders and prosecutors also consider whether the case is worth taking to trial. Sometimes a demand for trial leads the command to drop the matter or handle it administratively instead. Sometimes it leads to more serious charges.

What about a summary court-martial?

If you refuse NJP, the command may refer the case to a summary court-martial, a one-officer proceeding for minor offenses. You can object to trial by summary court-martial, in which case the command would have to use a special or general court-martial. A summary court-martial conviction is not considered a criminal conviction in most civilian contexts, but it can include confinement for enlisted members in lower grades. See what happens if you turn down an Article 15.

How the record affects your career

An Article 15 can affect promotions, reenlistment, school selection and security clearances, and it can be a basis for administrative separation. In the Army, the imposing commander decides where the record of NJP is filed, depending on your grade. In the Air Force, NJP is commonly placed in an Unfavorable Information File. Navy and Marine Corps NJPs are recorded in service records. See will an Article 15 ruin my career?

Questions to ask your lawyer before deciding

  • What evidence does the command have, and what would be admissible at trial?
  • If I accept, what is the realistic punishment from this commander?
  • If I refuse, what will the command most likely do?
  • Will NJP for this offense trigger separation processing or a clearance review?
  • Can I ask for a closed hearing, present witnesses, or have a spokesperson?

Example: two Soldiers, two different decisions

These are illustrative examples, not real cases.

Specialist A is offered a company-grade Article 15 for being late to formation three times. Her supervisor documented each incident, and she does not dispute being late. Demanding trial would gain her little: the facts are clear, and the worst Article 15 outcome is modest. She accepts, presents her strong duty performance and a family childcare problem as mitigation, and asks the commander to suspend any reduction.

Sergeant B is offered a field-grade Article 15 for an alleged assault at an off-post party. The only evidence is one witness who had been drinking heavily and whose story changed twice; two other witnesses say Sergeant B was not involved. Because the Army commander must be convinced beyond a reasonable doubt even at NJP, his defense counsel first argues the evidence at the hearing. If he expects the commander to find against him anyway, refusing NJP and forcing the government to prove the case under the rules of evidence may be reasonable, after careful discussion of the risk.

Branch differences that affect the decision

Branch NJP name Standard of proof at NJP Common record
Army Article 15 Beyond a reasonable doubt DA Form 2627, filed locally or in the AMHRR
Navy Captain’s mast Preponderance of the evidence Service record and evaluations
Marine Corps Office hours Preponderance of the evidence Unit punishment book and record
Air Force and Space Force Article 15 Preponderance of the evidence AF Form 3070, often an Unfavorable Information File

Because the standard of proof at NJP is lower in the Navy, Marine Corps and Air Force, a weak case is more likely to result in punishment at NJP there than at trial. That can make a demand for trial more attractive in those services when the evidence is genuinely thin.

Frequently asked questions

Does accepting an Article 15 mean I am admitting guilt?

No. Accepting only means you choose to have the commander decide the case instead of a court-martial. You can still deny the offense and present evidence.

Can I change my mind after accepting an Article 15?

Generally, once punishment is imposed you cannot switch to a court-martial. Make the decision carefully with counsel before you sign.

Can I refuse an Article 15 on a ship?

No. If you are attached to or embarked in a vessel, you do not have the right to refuse NJP.

Can a lawyer attend my Article 15 hearing?

You have the right to consult a lawyer beforehand. At the hearing, most services allow a spokesperson, who is not necessarily a lawyer, and the hearing is not a trial. See can a lawyer help me with an Article 15?

How long do I have to decide?

Your notice sets a reasonable deadline, commonly a few duty days, so you can consult counsel. Request more time in writing if you need it.

Sources

General information, not legal advice. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Last reviewed November 2026.